Wednesday, May 8, 2013

PEN; the remedy to combat NCDs

Do Bhutanese care about lifestyle? Do they realize the importance of prevention of Non-Communicable Diseases (NCDs) which is caused by physical inactivity, unhealthy diet, and tobacco and alcohol abuse? People never realize until tangible harm is seen. But, NCD is the primary health burden Bhutan is going through where majority of deaths is related to it, and poses a significant health expenditure- imparting economic burden on Government, families, and individuals.

The MoH report reveals- from a total of 208 deaths in 2003, it increased to 352 in 2009, which all are NCDs- alcohol liver disease, hypertension, heart diseases, diabetes, and cancers. The fact is that these NCDs are preventable with innovative public health approaches and responsive cooperation from people which would ultimately reduce the burden on the public health system and socio-economic condition of the country.


The medical reports on morbidity shows a rising trend of Non-Communicable Diseases in Bhutan, which poses a substantial health burden. During a Community-based survey conducted by the Ministry of Health (2007) in Thimphu, high prevalence of NCD risk factors was revealed. The survey indicated high prevalence of alcoholism, hypertension, and obesity. It also showed that about 66.6% of adults consumed less amount of recommended fruits and vegetables. Moreover, maximum people lived sedentary lifestyle, where 8.2% had high glucose level while 44.3% had raised cholesterol level.

Thus, with support from WHO, the Royal Government of Bhutan formulated policy for prevention and control of NCDs. They banned the sale of tobacco in public places. Smoking in public places was also prohibited. Further, with policy focused on health promotion and diseases prevention, numerous awareness campaign and advocacy programmes on importance of healthy diet and physical activity were adopted. Of all the initiatives, PEN project proposed by the WHO, and piloted in two districts of Paro and Bumthang is a new and efficient protocol integrated in our primary health system to combat NCDs.

 PEN intervention

“PEN project basically is prevention of NCDs and promotion of healthy life style like eating less salt, less oil, eating more vegetables, doing more exercise. Its protocol says it is a timely screening since early diagnosis can prevent early referrals of patients,” says Wangchuk Dukpa, senior programme officer under department of public health.

PEN stands for Package of Essential Non-Communicable Diseases interventions. The WHO developed PEN to provide technical guidelines for prevention of NCDs in Bhutan. PEN is a new concept and it is a consolidated type of protocol designed by the WHO, especially for screening and prevention of NCDs.
According to the MoH report, PEN intervention protocols are the tools to improve access of cost effective interventions to the community in the Low Middle Income Countries like Bhutan.

According to Wangchuk, PEN is a package of essential NCD intervention expounded by WHO, especially designed for low middle income country like ours. PEN is like some sort of protocol to give guidelines to health workers in peripherals in order to prevent NCDs, and carry out early diagnostics.
In 2009, health workers from 18 districts were sensitized on PEN intervention protocols. “The PEN was very new to Bhutan. In the first step, WHO experts came to Bhutan. We had meetings with many health workers. They discussed PEN in workshops, and later PEN was projected,” says Wangchuk.

With the financial and technical support from the WHO, PEN was initiated in two pilot districts of Paro and Bumthang, where staffs of Basic Health Units were trained in three day workshops.

“We did project to see how we can cope up with the guidelines drawn by the WHO. When we say project, we wanted to integrate this PEN intervention in our primary health system,” says Wangchuk.
To facilitate PEN project, additional equipment to measure blood glucose level and blood pressure were supplied to BHUs. WHO 10- year CVD risk prediction charts was provided along with making available of health education materials. To cater the basic needs of NCD patients, medicine supplies were increased in BHUs.

All NCD patients attending OPDs in health centers in pilot districts were registered and patients above 40 years were counseled on stopping smoking, reducing harmful use of alcohol, eating healthy food and enhancing physical activity.  They were screened for high blood pressure, obesity, tested for blood sugar level. Those found to have hypertension and life style disease like diabetes were registered to keep a clinical record for future follow ups.

As a result of PEN intervention, with the support from the WHO, two pilots PEN intervention were successfully implemented in Paro and Bumthang. It was found that the PEN intervention protocols were user friendly were most of the health workers could adopt it. Here Wanchuk says, ‘Before some sort of life style related diseases screening were there. Now, with PEN, it is more organized and integrated in health system as a fundamental protocol to prevent NCDs.’ 

After the PEN intervention was projected, the efficiency of various health centers improved, building up the capacity of health workers. And increased community awareness on major NCD risk factors indicated a proportion of achievement in prevention NCDs particularly through this PEN intervention.

The Way Forward

At the Mid Term Review of RGoB, serious concerns on NCD trends were recognized, and therefore advocacy and awareness campaign on prevention of NCDs were rendered top priority.
National EDL for extension of drugs to the district hospitals and BHUs will be revised through putting up proposals to the National Drug Committee.

To enhance the capacity of health workers to diagnose mellitus at early stage, glucometer will be included in all BHUs.

The PEN protocol will be reviewed and made available to all health centers. It will be expanded and integrated in all Dzongkhags. The PEN integration protocol will be incorporated into RIHS curriculum.
The health workers of entire country will be trained on PEN protocol intervention to incorporate with existing PHC system in order to control and prevention of NCDs.
  
(Draft Background research by Medaimax for WHO Bhutan)
 Image- Google

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

The 2nd UN Global Road Safety Week launched in Bhutan

The Second United Nations Global Road Safety Week, which will be observed from 6- 12 May, was launched by Road Safety and Transport Authority in collaboration with Ministry of Health at Royal Institute of Health Science, Thimphu on 6 May 2013.

The Ministry of Information and Communication’s Secretary Dasho Kinley Dorji presided as the chief guest, and WHO representative, a.i. Dr Khaled Hassan graced the day with his message on Global Road Safety Week. Various government officials, media personnel, Public Transport Service Operators, Taxi Operators, and students from Thimphu District participated in the programme.

To bring about awareness and address safety of the pedestrians who die due to road traffic injuries, this year’s theme was, ‘Pedestrian Safety.’ The event was funded by the WHO.

To mark the day, the WHO publication- Global Status Report on Road Safety, supporting a decade of action for road safety was launched along with RSTA’s Pedestrian Safety Pamphlet. 27 final artworks selected from 36 schools were displayed on the day to convey road safety message through art.

To observe the week, RSTA will initiate programmes where students will promote road safety awareness and pedestrian safety in and around the capital, Thimphu.

The chief guest’s message was, “Bhutanese people should not misunderstand road safety as the responsibility of RSTA and Traffic police. Neither should we view road crashes as the ‘transport’ problem. These are the serious problems involving the much broader human behavioral issue and requires the collective effort of all of us.”

In 2012, killing 96 people and injuring 611, stunning 1350 vehicles crashes were reported. Bhutan, translating to about 14 deaths for every 10000 registered vehicles in Bhutan.
One this day, RSTA and MOIC reminded all the motorists in Bhutan to drive responsibly, spread the road safety message, and to respect the rights of pedestrians.

According to Global Status Report on Road Safety 2013, road traffic injuries are the eight leading cause of death globally. Looking at the current trends, it will become the fifth leading cause of death by 2030 unless urgent action is taken. The synopsis of the report reveals that about 1.24 million road traffic deaths occur annually on the world’s road, in which middle- income countries are hit hardest, where 334815 people died from road traffic injuries in the South-East Asia Region alone in 2010. Every year, 1.24 million people die due to road traffic injuries.

Thus in 2010, with the goal to save 5 million lives over the decade, the United Nations General Assembly adopted Resolution 64/255 to reduce the increasing road traffic deaths around the globe, calling 2011- 2020 the Decade of Action for Road Safety.

The Global Road Safety Week will be observed all over the world to enrich opportunities to make roads safer for every pedestrian, and to draw global attention in generating proactive action on measures to protect pedestrians from road traffic injuries. 
In his Global Road Safety Week address, Dr Khaled’s message was, “Much can be done to make our world more walk-friendly and pedestrians safety through raising awareness among the public about related traffic laws and ensuring their enforcement; designing pedestrian-friendly road infrastructure; lowering vehicle speed limits; establishing and ensuring vehicle safety standards which protect pedestrians; restricting or diverting vehicles from pedestrian zones; improving the safety of routes to and from schools and in school zones can make a significant and long-lasting contribution towards making walking safer for the world’s pedestrians.”

He also acknowledged the Royal Government of Bhutan for taking several measures to ensure road safety, including establishing friendly foot paths, underpasses & pavements, strengthening traffic management & control system, observing pedestrian day each month & enforcing roads & vehicles safety standards.

Thanking the organizers and wishing success, Dr Khaled said, “on the occasion of the Global Road Safety Week, I am pleased to re-affirm the strong commitment of WHO to work with partners to make a significant contribution toward pedestrian safety.

  (MediaMax Draft report for WHO Bhutan)
    Image source- Google

Saturday, May 4, 2013

The Problem of Alcohol; a Collective Battle

In 2005, people were in normal disposition when the BBC aired a feature on growing burden of alcohol trends and its related problems in Bhutan. This is because, more recently the report by WHO revealed that Bhutan has the highest alcohol consumption figures in south Asian regions. 

Moreover, according to the records maintained by the Health Ministry, alcohol related disease ranked second in inpatient death in the year 2004 to 2008.

Globally, alcoholism is the 3rd killer disease next to heart disease and cancer. WHO report reveals that the harmful use of alcohol results in 2.5 million deaths every year. The global scenario of alcoholism is no different from Bhutan. Today, alcoholism has crept in as a clandestine problem, where it has affected individual’s health, wealth, happiness and wellbeing of a Bhutanese society. The substantial problems of alcohol divulged by facts and figures of various reports deem Bhutan as a microcosm of alcohol abuse.  

The problem of alcohol in Bhutan
Alcohol has not only affected urban centers, but also other parts of the country. According to a health survey (MoH) done in eastern Dzongkhags, more than 58 % of the respondents were found to be alcoholics. It also found that 50% of male respondents who were the sole bread earner were alcoholics, which led to many social and economic problems within the family and the community.

According to medical reports, alcohol liver disease was one of the leading causes for mortality from 2006 to 2010. Figures show that deaths due to alcohol liver disease escalated from 92 in 2005 to 169 in 2011, indicating a substantial upsurge from 15.2% to staggering 23%. 


RSTA report (2009) indicates that 7% of road traffic accidents in Bhutan are attributed to drunk driving. From 24 motor vehicles accidents, 2004, it increased to 118, 2010.
In 2010, the Forensic Unit of JDWNR hospital reported 1,093 cases of domestic violence; majority of cases were correlated to alcohol consumption. 

Royal Bhutan Police report shows a rife increase in juvenile crimes, all committed by adolescents, mostly under the influence of alcohol. Similarly, in majority of domestic violence cases reported to RENEW, alcohol abuse was a proximate cause.  

The Public Health Department has a huge financial burden in treating an alcoholic patient, where providing medical and health care to one alcoholic patient is around Nu. 120,000. And the cost of current treatment and rehabilitation for one alcoholic for three months is estimated at Nu. 48,000.

In rural Bhutan, rampant consumption of alcohol, along with massive production is found to be one of the causes for poverty, where maximum of grain produce were used in producing alcohol.

To generate revenue, the Royal Government liberalized sale of alcohol since 1999. There was an unprecedented increase in revenue which reached close to US$ 2.5 million annually. Nonetheless, the overall cost of alcohol related problems was massive, where increased alcohol revenues did not cover it.

The way forward
After numerous consultative workshops and meetings with stakeholders, the National Policy and Strategy to reduce harmful use of alcohol will be in place after GNHC submits it to the cabinet for endorsement. “Probably, the implementation will start in the 11th five year plan. We have submitted it to GNHC for screening. The cabinet will surely accept it. All the stakeholders have agreed after grueling brainstorming and deliberate consultations,” says a senior MoH official

According to the Health Ministry’s documents, there are forthcoming future activities that will be implemented cautiously. During 11th FYP, Health Ministry will establish detox and treatment center for alcohol and drug dependence at Gidakom.

Along with training of more health workers, there will be development on Standard Treatment and Counseling Guide for alcoholics. Community Action Programme on reducing harmful use of alcohol will be expanded, and nationwide awareness and advocacy activities will be vigorously enhanced. More importantly, with support from WHO, more operational research and studies will be conducted.  

Since WHO endorsed a global strategic call to reduce harmful use of alcohol on all member states, Bhutan maneuvered painstakingly to combat the harmful use of alcohol, which is now gaining ground, and achieving positive result. 

(From Unedited Mediamax Archive. Referenced)

Thursday, May 2, 2013

The Problem of Unemployment

Overview
Unemployment is a problem widespread all over the world. It is an unpredictable plight. Trying to gauge the solutions through creating jobs is unfathomable. Many tried but failed. During President Clinton's tenure, he was applauded for creating countless jobs, but he was viciously criticized when many Americans lost their jobs when the Stock Market collapsed. Thus, unemployment is a problem that can be solved temporarily, but when economy fluctuates, it becomes a colossal predicament.
Image Source- google

Similarly, Bhutan is no exception. The government claims that economic growth has increased by 8 % and the unemployment rate has been reduced to 2.1%, beyond its target to reduce the rate to 2.5% by 2013 (State of Nation Report, 2013). The Labor Force Survey Report 2012 shows the total labor force of the country at 336,391. The Labor Ministry reports that 329,487 are employed; it means that only 6,904 people are in the unemployed category and hence the low unemployment rate of 2.1% is calculated. 

However, the youth unemployment rate juxtaposes the survey report as it is still soaring at 7.3 %. With rapid increase in number of job seekers every year, a total of around 140,000 jobs will be required in the 11th Five Year Plan and approximately, 21,000 job seekers will enter the labor market on an annual basis. This is mentioned in the Annual report (Fiscal Year 2011-12) of the MoLHR.
According to the Annual report, the projected number of job seekers for 2018 is 27,505, while the number for 2012 is 18,682. Job seeking Students who are Classes X and XII pass outs would add more to the unemployment ratio. The projected number for the above category is 13,083. The number of students studying in Classes X and XII falls around 21,308 in 2012., and 1,969 are the degree holders for 2012, which would escalate to 3,421 in the year 2018.

Tentative Causes 
* Cheap Indian Laborers; The Private sector is not able to absorb all the unemployed youth. The costs of Indian laborer are cheaper than Bhutanese laborer. Moreover, Indian laborers are willing to do manual job with low wages, whereas Bhutanese laborers are not specialized in construction related works. Indian laborers dominate Bhutanese labor market, and it inevitably contributes to unemployment.
    
A preference for civil service: Attitude of educated youth is also important factor causing unemployment; every year, thousands of university graduates enter job market. Owing to reasons like sustainability, job security, training opportunity etc, young high school, and college graduates prefer civil service than private jobs. However, the goal of our government is to maintain a small and efficient civil service. As a result, there is a less possibility of expansion, and only few hundred are selected for government job. Youth are encouraged to seek employment in private sector and corporate sector while private sector is struggling to expand and develop due to government policies.

White-collar jobs: Blue-collar jobs reflect a class hierarchy in the view of job seekers and they tend to desire white-collar jobs. Graduates feel that they deserve better opportunities since they acquire some educational qualifications. Because of reluctance to take up manual work has forced the country to seek workers from abroad. This leads to huge remittance of foreign currency and subsequently contributed to economic crisis. The evidences are clear from above mentioned points to say that unemployment in Bhutan is the issue confronting mostly the educated youth.

* Mismatch of skills and jobs: The rising unemployment among the youth is due to the mismatch of skills the job seeker posses and the demand in the job market. Due to development programmes, major demands in job market are that of technical graduates. Hydro-power projects have created ample jobs for engineers and technical related course. However, work experience required hinders fresh graduates to get appropriate jobs. Moreover, general graduates are in the highest category of graduates in the country, and only less proportion of them are recruited in government and private sector. Thus, it further leads to rise in youth unemployment. Despite the fact that unemployment rates are rising, Bhutan still faces a crunch in the skill-based professions such as teachers, engineers, physicians and nurses, etc. While we still lack skilled laborer on one hand, the booming construction industry has given rise to the need of skilled laborer on the other hand. Thus, not only the mismatch of skills existed in labor market but there is also a mismatch between demand and supply in the job market. We have job seekers who are not able to find employment and at the same time, we do have employers who are not able to hire enough skilled and knowledgeable employees.

Migration: In addition, Youth Unemployment rate is found higher in urban areas as youth are migrating from villages to urban places in search of jobs as they are attracted by urban facilities. As a result, towns like Thimphu and Phuentsholing are flooded with youth. These youth fail to find suitable job and adds to unemployment rate, and at the same time, their villages are left with elderly people, which has led to uneven distribution of labor.

Recommendation
Provide skill based training: The challenge Bhutan faces today are providing its youth a gainful employment. To solve this problem the government should provide skill based training and orientations to young school dropouts and graduates so that they can gain appropriate skills required for jobs.

Encourage youth to join blue-collar jobs: Youth are not willing to take up blue collar jobs. With educational qualification they look down on blue-collar jobs. While most of the Bhutanese studying abroad do manual part time jobs, it shows that youth would take blue collar-jobs if provided with better services and better wages. In this case, the government should support private sector with subsidies and tax reduction, so that they can increase growth and hire indigenous laborers with better remuneration.

Private sector development: Government should support private sector as it is the largest employer in the country. Government should come up with certain economic policies such as minimal restriction on business companies so that it would enhance private sector. Private sector employing Bhutanese laborers should be benefited with tax subsidy, so that they could employ more Bhutanese youth.

Promote entrepreneurship: To create employment and economic growth, the government should support young entrepreneurs with appropriate training. They should have easy access to credit and licence. Customs tax and sales tax should be relaxed so that that they can grow faster. This would not only add to total economic growth, but also reduce the rate of unemployment.

Reform academic system: Changing academic system would be difficult, but this would be the only sustainable solution to ever growing unemployment problem. To meet the needs of altering economy, conventional Bhutanese academic system must be reformed. The curriculum should integrate proactive and practically applied lessons, which are responsive and in sync with the growing demand of Bhutanese job market. 

Rural Development: The government should focus more on developing rural places rather than disbursing maximum funds in central. Development should be incorporated with trickle-down policies, so that economic growth would benefit the poor community. Rural districts and Gewogs should have better public services like credit, banking, ICT, hospitals, entertainment center etc, so that youth would find jobs there, and stop migrating to towns.

In words of his majesty the fourth king: “The future of a nation lies in the hands of younger generation.”  On other hand, Unemployment in Bhutan has crippled our potential youth to stay idle rather than become capstone of development. Therefore, there is a responsive and collective need  to address such issues and frame policies to ease such problems.
  
(From Unedited Archive of Mediamax)
      This article is referenced.